Marketing Securities Online Is Different From Marketing Everything Else: Three Basic Rules To Follow To Avoid Trouble

Kendall Almerico - General Counsel, Cultivate Capital Group LLC

August 29, 2024

Since the advent of the internet, we live in a world of constantly being marketed to. Back in the "good old days" it used to just be TV and radio commercials, junk mail in the mailbox and ads in newspapers and magazines. You could easily avoid or ignore them. You could change the station on the radio when commercials ran. You could fast forward past taped TV ads in shows, or switch channels while watching live. Newspapers had ads, but your eyes knew to ignore them. But today, wherever you are online, it's impossible to not be bombarded by ads. They are everywhere, and they are so well done that sometimes you do not even know you are seeing or hearing an ad.

This is truly the golden age of marketing. So much data is available that you can literally drop an ad in front of a group of people online in your exact customer demographic and have that ad tailor made for your product or services, then have that ad follow them everywhere they go online. Nearly everyone buys things online now, and we never have to look far to find what we want because the wonderful people at Google and Meta and Microsoft mine so much data that they can have an ad in front of you in seconds after you showed even the most remote indication that you are interested in buying something.

With the passing of the JOBS Act in 2012, we suddenly had the ability to sell something else online — investments in private companies and startups. Small businesses had a new tool to raise capital and the restrictions against advertising that existed for more than 80 years were gone. The prohibition against the general public investing in startups and small businesses that were not publicly traded were gone.

So why has this golden age of marketing not allowed free-wheeling, Katy-bar-the-door marketing of these securities online? Sure, we see ads for companies raising capital, but why are these ads so limited in what they say, or how they look?

This article will explore some of the reasons why marketing securities online is not as easy as marketing almost anything else online. It will also delve into some tips on how to stay out of trouble when your private company decides to sell securities using marketing and advertising online and in traditional media.

For the most part, this article will discuss three methods of raising capital online: Reg A, Reg CF, and reg D, Rule 506(c) which are all parts of the 2012 JOBS Act. Some of what I write may apply to all securities in general, but I'm mostly focused on how small businesses raise money online under these three JOBS Act laws to raise capital to try to become big businesses.

The First Step: Avoiding "Securities Fraud" in Marketing

I know what you're thinking. "I'm not committing fraud, I'm just running an ad to try to sell stock in my company!" The reason rules for marketing securities are different from the rules about selling almost anything else online is that if you screw up in your online securities ads, you may be guilty of what federal law refers to as "securities fraud." You could face civil penalties. You could face lawsuits. You could go to jail. This is serious stuff. Imagine running a relatively innocuous ad about how your company's new T-shirts are the best and most comfortable T-shirts in the world, and having someone knock on your door and arrest you. That never happens. But say that the stock you are selling in your company is the best investment in the world, and you can expect a knock on your door, or more likely a nasty letter from a state or federal securities regulator before a knock.

Securities fraud under federal law is the misrepresentation or omission of information to induce investors into purchasing securities. The primary applicable federal law is Rule 10b-5 of the Exchange Act of 1934. Rule 10b-5 states that criminal and/or civil liability may occur if (a) there was a misrepresentation of a material fact (2) done knowingly (3) that a securities purchaser relied on and (4) the reliance on the material misrepresentation caused a loss.

In addition, state governments may also impose civil and criminal liability on those engaged in securities fraud based on state laws. But for the most part, if you follow the federal law as it applies, you will almost always be in good shape with state laws.

The key here that makes securities marketing different is the absolute prohibition on misrepresentation in your ads. We have all seen ads for cereal, shoes, cars and almost every consumer good that say things we all know are simply not true. Companies selling products and services have, for decades, been given some leeway for "puffery" or certain exaggerations of marketing claims. The courts tend to use this test, or something similar, to walk the fine line between puffery and false advertising: Is the claim "blustering and boasting that no reasonable consumer would rely on?" If so, it is puffery and not false advertising. One court said "a general claim of superiority over comparable products that is so vague that it can be understood as nothing more than a mere expression of opinion" is puffery, and not false advertising.

Unlike the rest of the marketing world, there is no place for "puffery" when marketing securities. Don't expect the general rules of puffery above will be used when the SEC, a state securities regulator or a competitor makes a complaint or starts an investigation into a potentially false or misleading statement.

Under securities laws, you must be clear to not be false or misleading in any manner. When you plan to make any statement, or use any language or graphics in any marketing material, review it in the most critical fashion you can — not in the most favorable manner. Assume the regulator or court will construe it in the worst manner possible, not in a manner favorable to you. If it could be considered misleading, don't take any chances. Do not use it.

You do not want that knock on your door.

Here are the three basic rules to avoid committing securities fraud. Of course, there are just guidelines. In all instances, get legal advice from a securities lawyer.

Basic Rule 1: Be 100% Truthful and Use Verifiable Facts in All Marketing Communications

Ads, interviews, social media posts, emails and every other form of marketing need to be 100% truthful and all statements presented as facts must be 100% verifiable as true.

My basic rule is… if it could be read in any way as being misleading, do not say or use it at all. There is no reason to take a chance.

Securities regulators do not care about "puffery" and will look at any statement that exaggerates, even if it is not believable at all, to be a false or misleading statement and a violation of securities laws.

Basic Rule 2: Use Qualifying Words and Terms When Giving An Opinion

If you have to discuss anything uncertain (I'm not talking about something false or misleading) make sure you qualify your statements.

For example, if you want to talk about your product being the best in the marketplace, understand the fine line between these two statements:

(1) We have the best product in the marketplace.

(2) We believe we have the best product in the marketplace.

The second statement is clearly an opinion, and while it is best to avoid even these types of statements when discussing a securities offering, sometimes it happens anyway, especially in a live interview. In those cases, be sure to qualify your statement with "we believe" or "we feel" or similar language. It's not a perfect defense, and if the words after the qualifying statement are false or misleading, then qualifying it will not help. But always train yourself and your marketing team to qualify any opinion statement that cannot demonstrable be proven as fact to give your company the best chance to avoid problems.

Again, review all securities marketing statements in the most critical and negative way before using them because that is how a regulator or court will read them. They do not care if you interpret what you said differently. Your opinion as to how it could be interpreted the way you want it to be interpreted means nothing in this context. That is not how a regulator will interpret it.

Basic Rule 3: Avoid Making Statements About Future Projections Unless There Are Lots of Disclaimers and Qualifying Language

Projections of future sales, revenues, profits, etc. are rarely accurate, despite everyone's best efforts. Once those projections are made public, they become fodder for regulators and plaintiff's lawyers to make claims that you promised something that was false or misleading. It's better to stay away from projections altogether. I almost always advise my clients to not use projections at all to promote the sales of their securities because of their uncertainty and the potential liability. But in circumstances where projections are used despite the great risk they bring to the table, there should be significant and thorough disclaimers surrounding the projections if they are in writing. If used in a media interview, they should be tempered by qualifying words and language — and best to do so in excess of what I discussed above given that you are talking numbers that people will rely on to make investment decisions.

But in my opinion, the best policy is to not use projections at all when marketing securities online.

This article was edited and is reprinted with permission from Kendall Almerico, general counsel for Cultivate Capital. The content is not to be considered investment advice of any kind, and is simply for educational purposes. The article is not to be considered legal advice from Kendall Almerico or his law firm. In all instances, you should consult your own investment or legal advisors and should not rely on this article for anything other than general informational purposes. The article, in its original form, was published at https://medium.com/@KendallAlmerico/marketing-securities-online-is-different-from-marketing-everything-else-three-basic-rules-to-f373189ce6a9

www.CultivateCapital.org is a website owned and operated by Cultivate Capital Group, LLC (“Cultivate Capital”). All Regulation Crowdfunding activities on www.CultivateCapital.org are conducted by Cultivate Capital, a broker-dealer registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and a member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).

All securities listed on www.CultivateCapital.org are being offered by the applicable issuer of such securities and all information included on this website related to those securities is the responsibility of each such issuer. The information on our website regarding any issuer or in a blog post is based on publicly available information or directly from the subject issuer. Cultivate Capital and its affiliates make no representation or warranty as to the adequacy, accuracy or completeness of such information. Any written materials on our website have been prepared solely for informative purposes and are not a solicitation of an offer to buy or an offer to sell any security. Cultivate Capital does not give investment advice, recommendations, or analysis as to any securities through www.CultivateCapital.org or in any other manner, nor does it endorse or recommend investments in any company or the suitability of an investment for any particular investor. Cultivate Capital does not provide any legal or tax advice with respect to any securities. Neither Cultivate Capital nor any of its officers, directors, agents, registered representatives and/or employees makes any warranty, express or implied, of any kind whatsoever related to the adequacy, accuracy, or completeness of any information submitted by or presented. No securities offered on this website have been recommended or approved by any federal or state securities commission or regulatory authority, including but not limited to, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

By using www.CultivateCapital.org, you accept and agree to be bound by the site's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy as may be amended from time to time without notice or liability. Please be aware that Cultivate Capital or its affiliates receive fees from issuers posted on our website at www.CultivateCapital.org. Details about our compensation are disclosed in the offering materials for each issuer conducting a live offering. Cultivate Capital may choose to compensate outside sources to help market our business and to receive introductions to possible issuers. Compensation to such parties will not be based on the success or size of any transaction and fees will not be based directly or indirectly on the purchase or sale of any security. Blog posts or the posting of information on our website regarding any issuer, including any links to information either in the blog post or on our website, should not be construed as an endorsement or recommendation of that issuer for any purpose whatsoever. Links are provided for information only and Cultivate Capital and its affiliates are not responsible for any information at the sites linked to. Blog posts or the posting of information on our website does not take into account the investment objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular investor, and each investor should consider whether any investment opportunity is appropriate given their investment objectives and current financial circumstances. Any person considering any investment is encouraged to consult with their own investment or financial advisor, tax advisor and/or attorney before making any investment.

All investments entail risk. The issuers on our site are generally small or early-stage companies and are subject to risks inherent in investing in any small or early-stage company as well as other risks specific to their business and operations. In addition, securities of these issuers may be highly illiquid, requiring that they be held for an indefinite period of time or have a limited market for resale. Therefore, no one should invest in any of these issuers unless they have no need for liquidity of their investment and can sustain a total loss of their investment. You should only invest an amount of money that you can afford to lose without changing your lifestyle. You should thoroughly review the complete offering materials for any investment opportunity, particularly all risk factors, prior to investing in any offering and become familiar with the investor requirements, investment limits and your ability to resell the investment.

202-909-8247

CULTIVATE CAPITAL GROUP LLC IS A MEMBER OF FINRA.

CRD#: 300634 SEC#: 8-70293

RESOURCES:

Educational Materials